---
title: Public Spaces Bylaw - A cycling Perspective
description: The Public Spaces Bylaw unfairly targets vulnerable communities while failing to hold those who impose the most harm onto the public and public spaces accountable, leading to over-policing and missed opportunities for real public safety improvements.
---

[Skip to content](https://yegbike.info/bike-blog/public-spaces-bylaw-a-cycling-perspective#main-content)

[![YEG Bike Coalition Logo - Horizontal](https://yegbike.info/hs-fs/hubfs/YEG%20Bike%20Coalition%20Logo%20-%20Horizontal.png?width=500&height=177&name=YEG%20Bike%20Coalition%20Logo%20-%20Horizontal.png)](https://yegbike.info)

- [Home](https://yegbike.info/)
- [Resources](https://yegbike.info/tools)
- [Events](https://yegbike.info/events)
- [Blog](https://yegbike.info/bike-blog)
- [About](https://yegbike.info/about)
  
  Show submenu for About 
  
    - [Contact](https://yegbike.info/contact)
    - [Bike Lanes?](https://yegbike.info/bike-lanes)

Open main navigation

Close main navigation

- [Home](https://yegbike.info/)
- [Resources](https://yegbike.info/tools)
- [Events](https://yegbike.info/events)
- [Blog](https://yegbike.info/bike-blog)
- [About](https://yegbike.info/about)
  
  Show submenu for About 
  
    - [Contact](https://yegbike.info/contact)
    - [Bike Lanes?](https://yegbike.info/bike-lanes)

 Jan 29, 2025, 3:50:56 PM

# Public Spaces Bylaw - A cycling Perspective

![Picture of Aaron Budnick](https://yegbike.info/hs-fs/hubfs/Aaron.jpg?width=50&name=Aaron.jpg) [Aaron Budnick](https://yegbike.info/bike-blog/author/aaron-budnick)

Share: [facebook-f icon](http://www.facebook.com/share.php?u=https://yegbike.info/bike-blog/public-spaces-bylaw-a-cycling-perspective) [linkedin-in icon](http://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?mini=true&url=https://yegbike.info/bike-blog/public-spaces-bylaw-a-cycling-perspective) [Twitter icon](https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?url=https://yegbike.info/bike-blog/public-spaces-bylaw-a-cycling-perspective) [pinterest-p icon](http://pinterest.com/pin/create/link/?url=https://yegbike.info/bike-blog/public-spaces-bylaw-a-cycling-perspective) [envelope icon](mailto:?body=https://yegbike.info/bike-blog/public-spaces-bylaw-a-cycling-perspective)

The [**Public Spaces Bylaw (Bylaw 20700)**](https://pub-edmonton.escribemeetings.com/Meeting.aspx?Id=b7b91007-6702-47f2-968d-22bfc62ed224&Agenda=Agenda&lang=English&Item=22&Tab=attachments) claims to improve public safety, but in reality, it **targets vulnerable communities while ignoring those who are most dangerous in public spaces—drivers**. This bylaw **criminalizes survival, duplicates existing laws, enforces vague restrictions, and increases over-policing** without offering real solutions.

[Read more about why we believe the ban on sidewalk cycling is misguided](https://yegbike.info/bike-blog/the-case-for-sidewalk-cycling-why-edmontons-ban-is-misguided).

Let's be clear, though there are new fines related to sidewalk cycling, these bylaws will mostly not be directed at the majority of cyclists. These fines are intended to be deployed against the most vulnerable amongst us, and will do little, if anything at all, to improve safety for anyone in the public realm. Additionally, if the data provided by administration is accurate (that sidewalk riding is less safe for cyclists themselves), then the multi-use paths being constructed as part of the Active Transportation Network Rapid Expansion program are also unsafe (they are effectively wide sidewalks that have every issue that was idenitfied in [attachment 8](https://pub-edmonton.escribemeetings.com/filestream.ashx?DocumentId=247119)). You can learn more about why we think banning cycling on sidewalks in unjust and inappropriate here.

Beyond cycling specific changes, this bylaw claims to address public safety, and perceptions of public safety, yet does nothing at all to alleviate the root causes that lead to crimes of desperation, nor does it address the single largest cause of safety incidents in the public realm.

This bylaw will make safety worse in the City of Edmonton, let's explore why.

**🚘 Missed Opportunity: Driver Accountability**

The bylaw unfairly **targets pedestrians, cyclists, and transit users while ignoring driver infractions**. Key missing provisions include:  
✅ **Illegal parking in bike lanes, crosswalks, and sidewalks**  
✅ **Blocking intersections and bus stops**  
✅ **Failing to yield to pedestrians and cyclists**  
✅ **Vehicular intimidation (rolling forward aggressively, honking at pedestrians)**  
✅ **“Dooring” cyclists by opening car doors without checking**  
✅ **Speeding in pedestrian-heavy zones, school areas, and transit corridors**  
✅ **Hit-and-run penalties—even without injury**

Right now, this bylaw **treats a cyclist on a sidewalk as more dangerous than a driver blocking a crosswalk or a car rolling aggressively toward a pedestrian**. Public safety is **not just about pedestrians and cyclists following rules—it must include drivers, who impose the greatest harm on others in public spaces**.

**🚨 5 Major Concerns: Why This Bylaw is Harmful**

**1️⃣ Potential Inequities for Marginalized Groups**

This bylaw disproportionately harms **unhoused individuals, racialized communities, and low-income Edmontonians**:  
✅ Criminalizes **sleeping in parks** despite inadequate shelter space  
✅ Penalizes **loitering in transit stations** without considering cold-weather survival  
✅ Bans **temporary shelters** without alternative housing solutions  
✅ Fines **scavenging for food or recyclables**, criminalizing poverty  
✅ Restricts **public gathering** with vague “interference” language  
✅ Lacks clear **protections for free speech and peaceful protest**  
✅ Criminalizes **public urination**, despite a lack of 24/7 public washrooms  
✅ Expands fines **without offering non-monetary alternatives** for those who can’t pay  
✅ Increases **discretionary enforcement**, leading to racial profiling  
✅ Targets **pedestrians and cyclists** while allowing drivers to create hazards

**2️⃣ Redundancies with Existing Legislation**

Many infractions **are already illegal under federal and provincial law**, making extra enforcement unnecessary:  
✅ **Public intoxication** is already covered under provincial law  
✅ **Loitering and public obstruction** are addressed in the Criminal Code  
✅ **Urination and sanitation issues** fall under the Public Health Act  
✅ **Public disturbances and disorderly conduct** are already illegal  
✅ **Scavenging laws** criminalize what is often a survival tactic  
✅ **Trespassing rules** already exist in Alberta law  
✅ **Graffiti and property damage** are already criminal offenses  
✅ **Cycling regulations** are covered under the Traffic Safety Act  
✅ **Existing police authority** is sufficient without bylaw duplication  
✅ **Double-penalization** creates confusion and increased legal burdens

**3️⃣ Restrictions on Activities Without Safe Alternatives**

This bylaw bans behaviors without first ensuring **safe, accessible alternatives**:  
✅ Bans **cycling on sidewalks** without building protected bike lanes  
✅ Fines **sleeping in parks** despite a lack of 24/7 shelter options  
✅ Penalizes **loitering in transit stations** without offering warming spaces  
✅ Criminalizes **public urination** without adequate washrooms  
✅ Bans **scavenging** without addressing food insecurity  
✅ Restricts **free movement** without investing in pedestrian-friendly infrastructure  
✅ Fines **small-scale vending and solicitation**, affecting those in poverty  
✅ Lacks exceptions for **emergency or medical situations** (e.g., washrooms)  
✅ Ignores **seasonal realities**—cold weather survival isn’t loitering  
✅ **Forces people into unsafe conditions** instead of solving urban mobility issues

**4️⃣ Ambiguities Leading to Enforcement Challenges**

Vague language **allows for racial profiling, selective enforcement, and legal confusion**:  
✅ “**Unreasonable interference**” is undefined and allows for biased application  
✅ “**Loitering**” is subjective and disproportionately affects unhoused people  
✅ Restrictions on **public gatherings and speech** could silence protestors  
✅ **Broad police discretion** leads to unfair enforcement against marginalized groups  
✅ Failing to define **public intoxication** increases over-policing risks  
✅ No clear exceptions for **public necessity (e.g., lack of washrooms)**  
✅ “**Aggressive solicitation**” is too vague, leading to arbitrary crackdowns  
✅ Overuse of **bylaw officers instead of outreach services** increases harm  
✅ Fines rely on **monetary penalties** rather than restorative justice  
✅ The lack of **public oversight** on enforcement increases risks of abuse

**5️⃣ Potential for Over-Policing**

Instead of **helping communities, this bylaw expands police interactions** for minor offenses:  
✅ **Over-polices unhoused people** while failing to address root causes  
✅ **Targets racialized and low-income individuals** through loitering laws  
✅ Increases **interactions with law enforcement for minor infractions**  
✅ Uses fines that create **financial hardship and cycles of debt**  
✅ Focuses on **enforcement over harm reduction services**  
✅ Criminalizes **poverty instead of offering support**  
✅ Expands police presence in public spaces **without justification**  
✅ Allows for **bias in ticketing and arrests**  
✅ Disproportionately affects **youth, gig workers, and transit riders**  
✅ **Fails to reduce harm—only shifts responsibility to policing instead of solutions**

# **Conclusion**

**⚠️ A Broken System: What Edmonton Must Do Instead**

✅ **Pause this bylaw and conduct an proper equity review**  
✅ **Ensure fines for drivers are no lower than those for pedestrians and cyclists to actually make public spaces safer**  
✅ **Expand protected bike lanes before banning sidewalk riding, while allowing sidewalk riding in low pedestrian zreas or high traffic areas that do not have protected infrastructure or adequate snow clearing**  
✅ **Fund more 24/7 public washrooms before criminalizing public urination**  
✅ **Invest in shelters and harm reduction before penalizing survival behaviors**  
✅ **Replace punitive fines with restorative justice and community service options**  
✅ **Ensure bylaw enforcement does not disproportionately target marginalized communities**

This bylaw, in its current form, **fails to make public spaces safer**. Instead of **targeting those who impose the least harm while ignoring those who impose the most**, Edmonton must **revise this bylaw to ensure fairness, accountability, and equity for all residents**.

## Related posts

## [Why Edmonton’s Ban is Misguided](https://yegbike.info/bike-blog/the-case-for-sidewalk-cycling-why-edmontons-ban-is-misguided)

![Picture of Aaron Budnick](https://yegbike.info/hs-fs/hubfs/Aaron.jpg?width=50&name=Aaron.jpg) [Aaron Budnick](https://yegbike.info/bike-blog/author/aaron-budnick) 

 Feb 4, 2025, 2:07:22 PM

Edmonton’s Public Spaces Bylaw (Bylaw 20700) reinforces a long-standing ban on sidewalk cycling and...

[Read more](https://yegbike.info/bike-blog/the-case-for-sidewalk-cycling-why-edmontons-ban-is-misguided)

[![](https://yegbike.info/hs-fs/hubfs/image-png-Jan-24-2026-07-49-06-1893-PM.png?height=200&name=image-png-Jan-24-2026-07-49-06-1893-PM.png)](https://yegbike.info/bike-blog/w%C3%AEhkw%C3%AAnt%C3%B4win-neighbourhood-renewal-dont-miss-whats-already-working)

## [Wîhkwêntôwin Neighbourhood Renewal: Don’t Miss What’s Already Working](https://yegbike.info/bike-blog/w%C3%AEhkw%C3%AAnt%C3%B4win-neighbourhood-renewal-dont-miss-whats-already-working)

![Picture of Aaron Budnick](https://yegbike.info/hs-fs/hubfs/Aaron.jpg?width=50&name=Aaron.jpg) [Aaron Budnick](https://yegbike.info/bike-blog/author/aaron-budnick) 

 Jan 26, 2026, 11:18:36 AM

Wîhkwêntôwin (Oliver) is not a neighbourhood struggling to become vibrant. It already is. It is one...

[Read more](https://yegbike.info/bike-blog/w%C3%AEhkw%C3%AAnt%C3%B4win-neighbourhood-renewal-dont-miss-whats-already-working)

[![](https://yegbike.info/hs-fs/hubfs/YEG%20Bike%20(3)-3.png?height=200&name=YEG%20Bike%20(3)-3.png)](https://yegbike.info/bike-blog/what-edmonton-can-do-to-reverse-its-vision-zero-failure)

## [What Edmonton Can Do to Reverse Its Vision Zero Failure](https://yegbike.info/bike-blog/what-edmonton-can-do-to-reverse-its-vision-zero-failure)

![Picture of Aaron Budnick](https://yegbike.info/hs-fs/hubfs/Aaron.jpg?width=50&name=Aaron.jpg) [Aaron Budnick](https://yegbike.info/bike-blog/author/aaron-budnick) 

 Dec 2, 2025, 2:09:57 PM

Edmonton is now ten years into Vision Zero. Yet instead of driving traffic deaths toward zero,...

[Read more](https://yegbike.info/bike-blog/what-edmonton-can-do-to-reverse-its-vision-zero-failure)

[![Logo for YEG Bike Coalition featuring a Brompton](https://yegbike.info/hs-fs/hubfs/YEG%20Bike%20Coalition%20Logo%20-%20Horizontal.png?width=500&height=177&name=YEG%20Bike%20Coalition%20Logo%20-%20Horizontal.png "Logo for YEG Bike Coalition featuring a Brompton")](http://Edmonton%20Bike%20Coalition)

[Follow us on Facebook](https://www.instagram.com/yeg.bike/) [Twitter icon](https://bsky.app/profile/yegbike.bsky.social) [facebook-f icon](https://m.facebook.com/profile.php/?id=100083116491019) [linkedin-in icon](https://www.linkedin.com/company/yeg-bike-coalition/)

Copyright © 2026, Edmonton Bike Coalition

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "BlogPosting",
  "author" : {
    "@type" : "Person",
    "name" : "Aaron Budnick",
    "url" : "https://yegbike.info/bike-blog/author/aaron-budnick"
  },
  "dateModified" : "2025-02-04T22:01:32.632Z",
  "datePublished" : "2025-01-29T22:50:56.000Z",
  "headline" : "Public Spaces Bylaw - A cycling Perspective",
  "mainEntityOfPage" : {
    "@id" : "https://yegbike.info/bike-blog/public-spaces-bylaw-a-cycling-perspective",
    "@type" : "WebPage"
  },
  "publisher" : {
    "@type" : "Organization",
    "logo" : {
      "@type" : "ImageObject",
      "url" : "https://yegbike.info/hubfs/YEG%20Bike%20Coalition%20Logo%20-%20Horizontal.png"
    },
    "name" : "Edmonton Bike Coalition"
  }
}
```